I watched the video, and yes the oily used crunched filter is how my WIX filter looked after I took it out and yes the clean WIX filter that he showed is how it looked before I put it in, nice and straight filter elements. Yet my ACDelco filter looks the same when I put it in and after I take it out, no deformation and straight filter elements! Other than the oily dark look of course, being the only difference between a new and used looking ACDelco filter.
I snap the oil filter into the plastic cap first before I insert it into the mounting location on the engine block. Then I hand turn the cap into the block as much as I can, and bring out my Snap-on torque wrench set at 25Nm to finish off the job using the Lisle special socket, which you can pick up at any auto store or Amazon. By the way I put clean oil on the small o-ring on the end of the filter and the large o-ring on the plastic cap before assembly to ease them into their mating locations and decrease wear especially on the large o-ring.
This still alarms me and I will continue using ACDelco. Seems like Mobile now, as brought up in the video and Wix need look into this. Does anyone get a straight looking filter after an oil change with others brands they use like purluator, K&N, etc.? I agree, the filter element of the ACDelco is probably not as good as WIX, but if wix is being crunched in the engine block and therefore not filtering correctly or at all, I'd say it makes sense to stick with ACDelco. Don't you?
I always used ACDelco oil filter. I also used SuperTech Filters from walmart couple of times. None of them were crunched. Note that Walmart no longer carries SuperTech oil filter. The SuperTech filter I bought from Waltmart looked very decent and made from Korea
08 2LT White/Titanium, 4cyl/4spd
Born 04/08 Lake Orion
Like I said earlier, I use Purolator and it always comes out crunched when I change it. I admit I don't torque the cap with a wrench, I have been just tightening it as hard as I could which is probably helping the crunching of the filter.
I always use the NAPA Gold filters or Wix filters and only had that crunching effect on my first oil change in the Cobalt. The only thing that changed was putting a little bit of oil on the fitting where the filter snaps onto the cap and a little bit of oil on the end that slides into the block.
The plastic cap has a positive stop built in, so you can't over tighten it into the engine block. The o-ring seal on the cap is a confined radial seal, which has a set compression that is not determined by the amount of torque applied to the plastic cap. This is unlike the unconfined axial seals on the normal canister spin on type oil filter where the amount of torque applied to the canister changes the amount of compression on the seal. Therefore, the 25Nm torque recommendation on the plastic cover is so you have enough suggested torque to keep the cap from vibrating loose, but not too much that the cap breaks. Maybe the crunching is due to not lubricating the small o-ring on the front of the filter before installing. I believe Napa gold is just relabeled WIX, from what Napa has told me. Still I would have to believe the crunching effect is due to the filter not seating properly and therefore causing a gap where oil can bypass the filter altogether. I definetly see some positives to this type of filter over the screw on canister, but there are still a few Cons too!
The AutoGuide.com network consists of the largest network of enthusiast-owned enthusiast-operated automotive communities.
AutoGuide.com provides the latest car reviews, auto show coverage, new car prices, and automotive news. The AutoGuide network operates more than 100 automotive forums where our users consult peers for shopping information and advice, and share opinions as a community.