Chevrolet Malibu Forums banner
Status
Not open for further replies.
1 - 20 of 25 Posts

· Banned
Joined
·
808 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 · (Edited)
What do you think about the Malibu trade-IN Value? I bought my 08 in 2009 with 8100 miles on it. I upgraded to the DVD headrest for my two younger kids that added $2000 more on the price of the car. I have been considering trading the Malibu but the depreciation has been over whelming after looking up. Trade-in blue book value shows around 14000 or so. Bought the car for around 26-27 out the door. The new one's were pushing around the 30,000 for the LTZ. This car has dropped way too much in value. Have owned Honda's before this and did not drop as quick or as much as the Malibu has in Value. :eek: I NOW HAVE AROUND 14,500 MILES ON HER RIGHT NOW! I like the malibu just not the Problems!
 

· Registered
Joined
·
4,169 Posts
When I got my MS3 I made like I was gonna trade in the Malibu (ended up giving it to the wife and trading her car in). Mine is a '08 LTZ V6/A6 pretty loaded, 24K, mint. Without the 20's they at first offered me $13,500 LOL. After ALOT of back and forth it went all the way up to $16,500. So it can get better, you just have to work them. But overall the trade-in value blows. That is why I bought mine 6 months old with 4K on it. I let the first owner take the hit, and I got a great deal on it.
 

· Banned
Joined
·
808 Posts
Discussion Starter · #3 · (Edited)
That is the problem I am having with the Malibu, Don’t want to take the hit after putting thousands down and more money into the car. Like I have mentioned more than once I like the car and just wish I didn't have the problems with the car that I am having and have had with it. Other than that the only thing I wish is it got is better MPG with the V6. I personally think the 4 cylinder is not enough for this heavy car. That is the problem with the Malibu, you have to choose between fuel econmony and horse power and thier is nothing between. Anyways I am thinking really hard about new or just keeping the Malibu. I am leaning towards keeping her and hitting the Service department with everything problem that arises. The only problem is my bumper to bumper warranty will end very soon, if it has not already and my extended will kick-in to 2013 at $50.00 deductible for each visit. You guys have been very friendly and helpful with our car questions, concerns and problems. I just want to say, THANKS!!
 

· Registered
Joined
·
382 Posts
If you are having that many problems with the car why didn't you trade it in as a lemon long ago? We did after a year and 14k on the car and now 2 months later have a brand new Malibu sitting in the drive. You can also have them buy it back and go to another vehicle entirely. But you only had 18 months after buying it to do that.

Plus if you didn't know that buying a new car is the worst investment you can ever make then you should have done some more research. New cars depreciate a crap load the second you drive them off the lot. This is not a new thing but is worse now that the economy blows. Also it is well known that American cars depreciate faster then imports. If you do a little research you would have known this going in and could have adjusted to your liking. I plan on having this car till it falls apart but that is just the type of person I am and have been raised as. I don't replace a car till it can't be driven or costs to much to keep on the road then its worth.
 

· Premium Member
Joined
·
254 Posts
the only thing I wish is it got is better MPG with the V6. I personally think the 4 cylinder is not enough for this heavy car. That is the problem with the Malibu, you have to choose between fuel econmony and horse power and thier is nothing between.
3.5L V6 is in between :D, V6 power with great fuel economy. I get 31 MPG highway, I can get it up to 33 if I have the patience to on long trips, and I get about 19 in the city. My average, (and I drive the car pretty hard 3-4RPM shifts lol) I get 23 MPG.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
382 Posts
3.5L V6 is in between :D, V6 power with great fuel economy. I get 31 MPG highway, I can get it up to 33 if I have the patience to on long trips, and I get about 19 in the city. My average, (and I drive the car pretty hard 3-4RPM shifts lol) I get 23 MPG.
Hell I have the 4 and right now with 4k on it we get 19 city and 34 highway. That's with us trying to get good gas mileage in it.
 

· Banned
Joined
·
808 Posts
Discussion Starter · #7 · (Edited)
I only had the car for 11 months now . Bought it in October 2009. I don’t just rush to get a new Vehicle just because something new comes but I do trade-in after some time owning it and the miles start to add up or the car has long on going problems. The economy has been horrible and I wanted a newer car that I could run it for a very long time, more than normal than I would in the past. As far as researching the car, my sister owns 08 Malibu Hybrid and has not had problems with hers. I figured I would try to get these problems fix and hope that it will correct the problem. Do you look for a different car when something breaks when new? When you have to take the time every month or two OR three to the dealership and sometimes several trips until they find the problem is not enjoyable and a waste of my time and money especially when you buy a newer car that suppose to had Won several awards is a bunch of Cr-p. LET THE BEST CAR WIN! I have researched the internet and have been to the dealerships several times. As far as the resale value, my mistake was to by from a company with so many financial problems. But after owning four other GM Products I figure I give them a try again. The Malibu was completely redesigned and I just really like the car. Each car falls in at different resale levels, some more and some less. It all depends on much people are buying that particular car and how easy it is to resell at the highest price for that particular vehicle compared to others in its class. If you have a car that is not reliable and has many problems, it is not going to have a high resale value because most likely people won’t buy that car again like they do with a Accord or a Camry, just for a example. Quality has to be number one, Especially if it is used. So I did do my research more than once. That is the problem with people, they say one thing but when they are in the same boat it is a different story. Look on this site alone and you can see the Malibu has had it's problems and has not been bulletproof in any way. I bought the car because I liked it and had faith in this car with all the reviews, but I guess I was wrong. I hope that this is the end of the on going problems with the car and I can finally enjoy driving the car without worrying how soon I have to make another appointment at the dealership! PS. As for the MPG, do some research yourself and you will find that I am not off on the subject. Some of you guys are saying certain MPG and I have heard others on this site saying totally something different. Maybe it a GM problem, can’t keep their cars consistently the same. GOOD APPLE/BAD APPLE! Thanks for your input!!!!!!!
 

· Registered
Joined
·
382 Posts
I only had the car for 11 months now . Bought it in October 2009. I don’t just rush to get a new Vehicle just because something new comes but I do trade-in after some time owning it and the miles start to add up or the car has long on going problems. The economy has been horrible and I wanted a newer car that I could run it for a very long time, more than normal than I would in the past. As far as researching the car, my sister owns 08 Malibu Hybrid and has not had problems with hers. I figured I would try to get these problems fix and hope that it will correct the problem. Do you look for a diffrent car when something breaks when new? When you have to take the time every month or two OR three to the dealership and sometimes several trips until they find the problem is not enjoyable and a waste of my time and money especially when you buy a newer car that suppose to had Won several awards is a bunch of Cr-p. LET THE BEST CAR WIN! I have reached the internet and have been to the dealerships several times. As far as the resale value, my mistake was to by from a company with so many financial problems. But after owning four other GM Products I figure I give them a try again. The Malibu was completely redesigned and I just really like the car. Each car falls in at different resale level, some more and some less. It all depends on much people are buying that particular car. If you have a car that is not reliable and has many problems, it is not going to have a high resale value because most likely people won’t buy that car again like they do with a Accord or a Camry, just for a example. So I did do my research more than once. That is the problem with people, they say one thing but when they are in the same boat it is a different story. I bought the car because I liked it and had faith in this car with all the reviews, but I guess I was wrong. I hope that this is the end of the on going problems with the car and I can finally enjoy driving the car without worrying how soon I have to make another appointment at the dealership! PS. As for the MPG, do some research yourself and you will find that I am not off on the subject. Some of you guys are saying certain MPG and I have heard others on this site saying totally something different. Maybe it a GM problem, can’t keep their cars consistently the same. GOOD APPLE/BAD APPLE!
I think the reason for me saying research went way over your head. I stated that pertaining to the drop in resale value of the car after only a certain time frame.

If your having so many problems as was I then you should seriously look into a GM buy back due to it being a lemon. Its what me and the wife did. I literally walked in one day instead of dropping the car off I dropped off my typed letter and told them I wanted to file a lemon claim on it. A week later the GM rep called and we started going over the options and we found our new car. I loved the Malibu so much we decided to go with another one. So far so good just got a few little things that were messed up during assembly nothing serious like the last car heh. Mainly paint issues where the machine was not calibrated right and sprayed to thin or didn't cover the panel.

Again look up the local lemon laws in your area ASAP and file the claim with the dealer. Its really painless just the waiting game that takes about 2 months total. Prob less if you are not getting another car from them.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
135 Posts
Yup, that's the unfortunate reality of buying a New Car. They will depreciate like mad, and an American, especially a GM Product, save for maybe the new Camaro amongst perhaps some select others, will depreciate the worst.

I've "won" and "lost" quite a bit in the car buying/selling game, but my Malibu is fortunately one that I did right financially. I got it in May of '09, when the Used Car market was in the pits, for $12,900.

Toward the end of last year, leading into now, the Used Market REALLY has leveled out, and prices for every car are pretty considerably more than they were a year ago. I'm talking about cars that are 1 year older now, and have more mileage, equalling, or being even more than, the exact same car was, one year younger.
 

· Premium Member
Joined
·
59 Posts
The initial owner of the car paid over $29,000 for my 2008 Malibu LTZ.

I bought it off of him in July 2009 for $20,000 with 27,000 miles on the odometer.

Now if I want to sell it, or trade it in, I will only get $14,000-15,000 at 44,000 miles on the odometer.

I know that these cars are not an investment, and will lose value, but I was hoping that I would keep the car for 10+ years. With the problems that I am having with it, I will definitely not keep it that long, no way. Therefore I will lose a lot of money, $5,000 - $6,000 down the hole is a lot of money to me, and in just ONE YEAR of owning a top of the line, loaded USED car!?!?!?!?!?

Plus, I spent $1,300 on an extended warranty because I saw that my transmission was leaking, and my wheel bearing was making noise (this stuff would probably be covered under the powertrain warranty, but not all the OTHER parts non-powertrain related on the car that were going to break).

I have taken a very big financial hit with this car, I thought getting a used car will save me money, but the 2nd phase of depreciation from a 2nd owner (that I am experiencing) is just UNacceptable.

Chevrolet ripped off the first owner of this car BIG TIME, and as a second owner, I feel like I got ripped off too, THAT IS JUST BAD. The car is just not worth the price that the dealers sell them for. Car is cheap, and will break down all too often (I have been in the shop about once a month). I actually hate driving it, it is no fun at all anymore. Everything was fine when I first got it, but the parts and material quality are below grade, refinement went downhill very fast, and stuff just breaks that shouldn't break so soon. The steering and all the sutble knocking and clunking from this car actually makes my life miserable, it makes me angry and annoyed. Driving the car to and from work should be a somewhat fun, BUT IT IS NOT. I can't believe that I'm stuck with this car right now, I don't feel like selling it and losing money, but I also don't want to keep it.

I have only had GM cars in the past, but they were all 15+ years old, and they were fine. I thought getting a much newer one will be worlds ahead of what I used to own, but that is definitly not the case, this car is worse, and breaks down way more often than my old GM cars did.

These new vehicles that Chevrolet puts together just don't seem solid. I sometimes wonder why is my GM dealer so damn busy with fixing all these new Chevrolets??

Thanks a lot GM. How can you keep assembling and selling these type of crappy cars... if I could take back my purchase, I would do it in a heartbeat. I made a BIG mistake buying this car. The dealers and the cars are very deceptive, they did a nice bait and switch to me.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
4,169 Posts
The initial owner of the car paid around $29,000 for my 2008 Malibu LTZ. I bought it off of him in July 2009 for $20,000 with 27,000 miles on the odometer.
You could have done even better then that, I bought mine in August of ‘09, (was 6 months old) with 4900 miles on it OTD (taxes 7%, fees and all) for $19,750ish.

Now if I want to sell it, or trade it in, I will only get $14,000-15,000 at 44,000 miles on the odometer.
Trade-in should be higher then that is the car is clean and you don’t take their first (crap) offer. I was quoted as high as $16,500 for mine last month, and I have seen local private sales for close to $19,000 in my area.

I know that these cars are not an investment, and will lose value, but I was hoping that I would keep the car for 10+ years. With the problems that I am having with it, I will definitely not keep it that long, no way. Therefore I will lose a lot of money, $5,000 - $6,000 down the hole is a lot of money to me, and in just ONE YEAR of owning a USED car!?!??!!?
Right, no car aside from maybe a Ferrari is an investment. Some GM cars just hold value better, Camaro, good, Malibu, not so good. One of the reasons I bought a Mazdaspeed3 this month, good resale.

I have taken a very big hit financially with this car, I thought getting a used car will save me money, but the 2nd phase of depreciation from a 2nd owner (that I am experiencing) is just UNacceptable.
Most cars are a “hit” if you wanna sell them soon after buying them, fact of life.

Chevrolet ripped off the first owner of this car BIG TIME, and I feel like I got ripped off too. The car is just not worth the price that the dealers sell them for. Car is cheap, and will break down all too often (I have been in the shop about once a month). I actually hate driving it, it is no fun at all anymore. Everything was fine when I first got it, but the parts and material quality are below grade, refinement went downhill very fast, and stuff just breaks that shouldn't break so soon. The steering and all the sutble knocking and clunking from this car actually makes my life miserable, when driving to and from work should be a somewhat fun. I can't believe that I'm stuck with this car right now, I don't feel like selling it and lose money, so I have to keep it and bear with it.
Ripped off, doubtful. If you car had a sticker of $29,000, the first owner most likely paid way, way less. Between working out a price, incentives, rebates, loyalties, etc, my guess is he paid under $25,000 at most. In all honestly, a lot of car for the money at the time. I don’t think you got ripped off, you didn’t get a bad price, just not the best. You just seemed to get a bad apple for sure. While my car has been far from perfect, and I am not happy with it overall, I have owned worse cars (Honda Accord V6, and Chrysler Sebring convertible, both my wife’s cars) so I can’t say that. Would I buy another Malibu? Honestly, nope. But now the car is in the wife’s hands, and for her short daily commute she loves it.

I have only had GM cars in the past, but they were all 15+ years old, and they were fine. But these new ones that they build just don't seem solid. I wonder why is my GM dealer so damn busy with fixing all these new Chevrolets??
Same here. I still own a ‘00 Camaro SS, tons of mods, raced all the time, still solid as a rock. I also owned a ‘95 Camaro Z28, ‘86 Camaro Z28, ‘07 G6 GTP, ‘99 Grand Prix GTP, ‘98 Malibu LS and '86 Olds 442. All of which were solid cars, with no real issues. Some bought new, some from from it. I to wonder, aside from a Corvette or Camaro if I will buy another GM car.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
50 Posts
The initial owner of the car paid over $29,000 for my 2008 Malibu LTZ.

I bought it off of him in July 2009 for $20,000 with 27,000 miles on the odometer.
Am I reading this correctly? You bought a used car with obvious problems with a warranty to mitigate the issues and now ALL Malibus are crap? I paid $17500 for my fully loaded LTZ with 10K on the clock last year and had one issue with the steering rack. The car has been solid otherwise. I have had over 8 newer cars from here and abroad and the Malibu compares quite favorably. One bad experience does tend to make one bitter but it seems every individual car is a bit of a gamble no matter the make/model. GM is a lot better than it used to be that's for sure but it will take a while for the reputation to recover and resale is partly perception. I would never ever think of a new car as any sort of investment and if I was worried at all about resale I would be driving a Civic, which defines cheap and boring.
 

· CMF Veteran Member
Joined
·
1,413 Posts
The thing with forums like this is, those who aren't happy tend to be loudest. I rather think there's a sizable majority out there who aren't going through problem after problem with the current generation Malibu.
 

· Banned
Joined
·
808 Posts
Discussion Starter · #14 · (Edited)
Called dealership today and they said they ran into more serious problem and it was more complex than originally thought. They have to order more parts for the transmission. The whole housing needs to be replaced. They said that the housing was pitted all over and no matter want seal they used would not work or correct the problem. At least another two days before car will be done after parts come in. Sorry if I sound like I am crying or Speaking out loudly but this is one for example of the new generation problems current owners arer facing on their new Malibu’s. This is not my fault, I blame GM Quality Control Inspection and their Workmanship. NOTE: NOT THE DEALERSHIP, THEY HAVE BEEN GREAT.
 

· CMF Veteran Member
Joined
·
1,413 Posts
Uh oh, I didn't mean to imply that you or anyone in particular are loud in a bad sense. That was just me being the contrarian. If anything, I think you've shown an amazingly cool and level attitude through your ordeal.
 

· Administrator
2011 Malibu LTZ 3.6L V6 Red Jewel Tintcoat
Joined
·
21,134 Posts
Uh oh, I didn't mean to imply that you or anyone in particular are loud in a bad sense. That was just me being the contrarian. If anything, I think you've shown an amazingly cool and level attitude through your ordeal.
I concur. I think you have stated your case well and kept your cool doing so.

I just wish the dealer's service department where I bought mine was half as capable and caring as yours.
 

· Premium Member
Joined
·
59 Posts
Trade-in should be higher then that is the car is clean and you don’t take their first (crap) offer. I was quoted as high as $16,500 for mine last month, and I have seen local private sales for close to $19,000 in my area.
My estimate of trade in value is pretty close ($14,000 to $15,000). That is what KBB says, and they do extensive research on car values in certain areas. I obviously don't live in your area. Any dealer giving more money for these Malibu's (as long as they are stock) is just stupid . Even THEY use KBB to come up with an estimate, I have sat with a sales person at their desk and they go to KBB.com and show me what the car is worth. Here are some screencaps of my car's value:

Trade In:



Private Party:



Ripped off, doubtful. If you car had a sticker of $29,000, the first owner most likely paid way, way less. Between working out a price, incentives, rebates, loyalties, etc, my guess is he paid under $25,000 at most.
You cannot go and assume everything. I spoke to the original owner, and he paid a little over $29,000 for it OTD, he gave me the title at the time, showed me the invoice, and a photocopied check for what he paid for.

I don’t think you got ripped off, you didn’t get a bad price, just not the best.
There was a time I had shopped for a NEW Malibu LTZ, and the prices that I was quoted were between $27,500 and $29,000 OTD, always walked away on the offer, and the dealer would call me the next day to see if I changed my mind, but they would never go any lower than those numbers. And I went to quite a few dealers. They wouldn't budge or give me a lower price. At the time I didn't want to cough up almost 30 grand for a car.

After looking at over 15 USED Malibu LTZs, $20,000 was the best price I could find in July 2009, in the Chicago Metro area. Originally the guy wanted $22,500 for it, but I told him I'll pay $20,000 cash. In July 2009, here near Chicago, the Malibu LTZs did cost a lot. $20,000 was the best price I found for a flawless vehicle at the time, the radiator had no chips, nor even a mosquito corpse.

Am I reading this correctly? You bought a used car with obvious problems with a warranty to mitigate the issues and now ALL Malibus are crap?
Sorry, I re-read my post and I can see how it can be confusing. I cannot explain every detail in the car's history... So when I purchased my car, I had lifted it and it was spotless underneath, nothing was wet, no leaks, and the ride quality was very good, not a noise to be heard from the any part of the vehicle. But around 32,000 miles (a year after purchase), when I was changing the oil, I saw the transmission was wet, so the dealer replaced the seal. Around 35,000, my wheel bearing was making noise and the car was hard to control on the highway, so the dealer replaced that too. While I was at the dealer with 35K miles, I bought the extended warranty because I had a feeling I would have more problems with the car. I did not buy a used car with obvious problems. I thought I was buying a car that won Car of the Year, a prestigious award. After having these problems with my car, and reading other owner's issues on this site, I have concluded that the 7th Generation Malibu is crappy, but covered with nice looking frosting and a plump cherry on top to make it look good (I am making reference to the attractive exterior).

The extended warranty has come in handy so far, dealer replaced door actuators because they would not go up or down, and they replaced upper strut mount bearings because of a clicking noise when turning. They also replaced two fuel injectors because they were "sticking" and the car would stutter (and I only buy top-tier gas, and use GM's own Fuel Injector cleaner as prescribed). All these problems would not be covered by the Powertrain Warranty, and the car had over 36K miles.

Proof: http://www.chevrolet.com/owners/warranty/

The above link is for the 2010 warranty, I have a 2008, but the 2010 warranty hasn't changed much from the 2008 one.

To conclude, the car's quality has deteriorated way too fast for something that is only 2.5 years old.

Sorry if I sound like I am crying or Speaking out loudly but this is one for example of the new generation problems current owners arer facing on their new Malibu’s. This is not my fault, I blame GM Quality Control Inspection and their Workmanship. NOTE: NOT THE DEALERSHIP, THEY HAVE BEEN GREAT.
I also want to inform the members of this board of the issues I have experienced with my car. I don't see how the problems I have had with my car are my fault. Its GM's fault for cost cutting, and using inferior - below grade parts and materials. I can't be blamed for a leaky trans and failed door locks, and steering clunks.

My dealers have also been good on repairs, they obey my little post-it-note on the radio that says "PLEASE DO NOT WASH, THANK YOU." If I had the time, would send them a thank you card so they can post it on their "Satisfied Customers Who Had Their Car Worked On Here" bulletin board in the waiting area. The only thing I absolutely hate is scheduling an appointment, and taking time off work to get something fixed on my car, which happens all too often, I have even used up Vacation time to get my car fixed.

Thank you Silver LTZ and LTZeeeee for critiquing my first post in this thread, I hope that this post provides evidence for what I said in my first post.

So to get back onto topic. I agree with the original poster, 08chevymalibultz, and think the 7th Generation Chevrolet Malibu has a poor resale value for something that is touted as an award winning car. I don't think its even close to average, its just POOR, or is there something even lower than Poor, cuz I'd choose that. I'm entitled to my own opinion.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
4,169 Posts
Even THEY use KBB do come up with an estimate
Actually, they don't. They use something called the "Black Book". They lead you to believe the use KBB or NADA. Either way, the trade in can be and should be worked on. And never tell them you have a trade in until after you have a deal worked out. When we traded the wife's car in we got $950 more then excellent trade-in. It can be done....
 

· Banned
Joined
·
808 Posts
Discussion Starter · #19 · (Edited)
Silver LTZ I think you might be right about the Black Book Value. If you look at many online Dealership Websites this is what they post to look-up your Trade-in Value but when I bought my Malibu they had posted the Kelly Blue Book in the window of the car. I am Not sure which one gives more for Value, have not looked up to compare but $950 or a little more does not justify in this kind of drop in Value. I am sure we agree or are the same page, so to speak. I understand what you are saying, don't agree on what they offer in the begining and try to talk them to bring up the numbers for the Trade. I have done this before and sometimes it works and other times it does nothing. Some dealers will give you their bottom line price on the New Car but will not move on Trade-in Value numbers. I know a lot of Malibu owners are excited and proud of the ownership of their car but have to agree with BLINKQS about letting others know about his/our problems with the current model that we are having with the Malibu. I understand his frustration and disappoint with the Malibu. Some of the guys go on attack when someone post their problems they have had with the car but the Truth needs to be told if the car has serious problems. If some guys didn't have any problems with their Malibu, that is great news and I am happy for them. I know no one wants to hear that their Car Model is a piece of Cr-p or poorly made but the list of complaints and problems start to speak for itself, at least saying there are a list problems that continue from one owner to another. I would love to say the car has been Great and has meet all my expectations and with no real big problems, but I can’t say that at all. I know my sister has had good luck with her Malibu . After the Dealership does their final touches on the car, I am hoping that is the end of my car problems. Let’s face it we bought our Malibu’s because we liked them a lot. All and All the car problems do exist on the Malibu, some way too much for a new/newer car. The RESALE VALUE does suck/blow or what ever you want to call it because it is really low period. I hope that GM Rep. that was on this site before are taking notes. I will give this car a chance and try to work-out the problems with the dealership but if the car continues to add to the problem list and I have no choice on getting rid of the car and have to take thousands of dollars lost, I can honestly say for sure this will be my last GM Vehicle..
 

· Registered
Joined
·
4,169 Posts
I am Not sure which one gives more for Value, have not looked up to compare but $950 or a little more does not justify in this kind of drop in Value.
The $950 more we got was on the wife's '08 PT Cruiser we traded in which was much less then the Malibu when new, so a $950 jump was great. I got them to go up about $2000 on the Malibu, but we decided to keep that for her.
 
1 - 20 of 25 Posts
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top